Butter or Margarine - which one is better for my health?

84

By akeejaho

Butter or plastic? Hmmm.

Yes, you read that right. I will explain in just a moment. But, to quickly answer your question, I would have to say, Butter is far more healthy than margarine. Though, I do know there are those who would disagree with me. There are those who would choose the latter. I don't fault them for that, nor do I say they are wrong. (That would make me look so opinionated.) -However, in my opinion, they would be just sooooooooo wrong!-

Why do you say that, Akeejaho?

Thanks for asking.

First of all, if you have ever read any of my Hubs, you might notice that I am a Naturalist. (No I don't garden in the Nude.) I do, though, lean toward a diet that is as close to Natural as possible. I have too.

Again, if you have seen any of my Hubs, you may or may not notice that I am a Bipolar. More, I control my Bipolar in a different way than most. I control it by adjusting my surroundings, my food intake, and my stress. I do not take any of the medications that are available to fight manic/depression. I find personally, the affects of the drugs, and the side effects caused by them are often times worse than the Syndrome they supposedly help to control. Worse, the combinations that some of the "Doctors" can come up with make you more like a walking bag of soup than a viable, useful human being with something to offer society at large. (Not that I do, but I do try!)

By controlling what I take in, I find I can (sometimes) lesson the twists and turns Bipolar Syndrome throws at an individual. (Except for last week!) By having peaceful surroundings, by keeping a healthy diet of good foods that are as natural as possible, and controlling the negative situations which lowers my stress, I pretty much move along one foot at a time.

Healthy food is important. Important to everyone, Bipolar or, as I term those who are not, the "Normy's". Good healthy food is the basic fuel our bodies need to function. The source for everything the body needs to produce cells, enzymes, chemicals key to our survival is found in the foods we eat. (Wow!, I sound like a nutritionist.)

With me so far?

Foods that are processed and made from something else to make something nature already has is really an amazing feat, but in my opinion, a very large waste of time, money and resources. (Kinda like Washington DC, but that's a Hub in itself.)

The human body is far more capable of breaking down natural foods than those that are processed with chemicals and whatnot. Butter is a product of those big fuzzy beasts you see out munching on grasses and stuff. You know. Umm, oh yah. Cows. While margarine is made from stuff that came from other resources. Oils and preservatives, and stuff to keep it from spoiling.

Side thought. I sorta feel jealous of future archeoligists who stumble across the ruins of one of our grocery stores. They will find a virtual feast of processed foods that will probably be ready to eat!

Butter is best in my opinion, because it is so close to nature as you can get. Especially if you purchase sweet butter. It is fresher. Salted butter is okay if you do not have to control your salt intake. But that is what the choices are. Sweet or salted. Not preservatives, no spun oils, no artificial ingredients, wrapped in wax paper and not in a plastic tub (that can make nifty cereal bowls) to further taint your foods.

If you want to remove the solids, you can render the butter down. This is called Clarifying butter. In doing so, you end up with a pure butter. The solids drop out in this process and what rises to the top is pure butter flavor, and a liquid that won't burn easily when used for sauteing foods.

How come?

Because the solids are the part of butter that burn. And by adding olive oil to the pan with an equal amount of clarified butter, you can raise the cooking temp with even less of a chance of burning, lessening the harmful oxidants which can cause cancer.

Oh.

Some say the cholesterol in butter is bad for you. What they don't tell you is that there are good cholesterals in there too. With a proper diet, this fear is lessened. I have eaten butter for years, and my counts are far below the national average. (guess I got good Genes!)

So, in answer to your question, Butter is better.

In case you need one more point if you need one. Margarine is not far orr from plastic, if you look at it from a molecular perspective. So, what do you want with your bread? Butter or plastic?

If you want to learn more about Bipolar, check out some of my other Hubs, or watch for the one I am working on now, titled "Tick..Tick..Tick...Defusing the Bipolar time bomb".

Comments

akeejaho profile image

akeejaho Hub Author 3 years ago

Thanks Emma, for all the information you shared. I guess you didn't bother to read the comments or you would have noticed that after Funride pointed out my mistake, I mentioned that the plastic thing was indeed, an urban legend.

Anyway, I don't care what the arguement for margarine is, I prefer butter, and will argue till You are blue in the face, that, and I repeat, natural foods are better for an individual than anything that man can conjure up using what ever ingredients they wish to mush together. Further, anything in moderation is far less harmfull than eating processed or created foods. Half of Our health issues come from eating processed and containerized foods, and that is an arguement I can support with fact.

However, I understand where you are coming from. With heart disease already in your family, you can hardly afford to take chances. Thanks for leaving the links. I have already been to them, (I do alot of research) and there is alot of good information for those who choose to venture there.

Hope you continue to read my stuff and leave comments, whether you agree with me or not.

Emma 3 years ago

Yuck, who wants to eat plastic! But, not to worry margarine is not plastic. “Margarine is one molecule away from plastic” actually comes from an “urban legend” that has been circulating on the Internet since 2003.

Let’s get technical for a moment. Plastic is a polymer, whose ingredients may include polyvinyl chloride, polyethylene, acrylic, silicone, and urethane. Margarine is an emulsion of naturally processed vegetable oil, water, salt, vitamins, and other functional ingredients that ensure the safety and quality of the finished product. Emulsions consist of two or more ingredients that naturally do not remain blended or “in suspension”; and need added ingredients to keep them together; think of it like oil and water. Other types of emulsified foods that you may eat include deli meats and salad dressings.

Living a healthy lifestyle includes eating moderate amounts of the right foods. For example, substituting soft margarine for butter. Margarine has 3 times less saturated fat than butter, not to mention beneficial polyunsaturated fats and Vitamin E. Yes, trans fat in margarine was once an issue but margarine producers have reduced trans fat levels to a miniscule amount comparable to that found in butter. I've been working with the National Association of Margarine Manufacturers so I've learned a lot about this particular topic. In addition, heart disease runs in my family so I have a personal interest in the subject as well. Check out the links below for more information:

http://www.margarine.org, http://www.snopes.com/food/warnings/butter.asp, http://www.cfsan.fda.gov/~dms/transfat.html#choice and

http://hp2010.nhlbihin.net/cholmonth/q_a.htm.

akeejaho profile image

akeejaho Hub Author 3 years ago

Butter has always been number one on my list also. I cook, and butter is something I have used to rescue dishes whose sauce needs a bit of help, (along with wine!), as well as for it's many other uses both in baking as well as cooking. Funny thing is, despite all the flap, I have suprisingly low cholesteral, a healthy heart, and all my parts still exist, and work. (But I am Bi-polar so some stuff works better than other stuff!)

I attribute my health to my diet, the exercise I get, and the fact that I live as naturally as I am able. I eat organic vegetables grown in our own gardens, fertilized only with good old home-brewed compost. Yup, natural is better!

Shalini Kagal profile image

Shalini Kagal Level 4 Commenter 3 years ago

I've always rooted for butter - never had margarine on our table! In fact I have the butter made at home. Gimme the good ol' natural stuff any day! Great hub!

akeejaho profile image

akeejaho Hub Author 3 years ago

Butter is Oh, so good in baking! And you can't beat it on fresh vegetables, out of the garden, with some Sea Salt and cracked fresh pepper. Yum, Yumm! Thanks for visiting Bobbie!

Bobbie Haws profile image

Bobbie Haws 3 years ago

I have often pondered the value of butter vs margarine. I grew up on margarine, because my mother bought into the healthier bit of the 70's promos for it. I have to admit that I actually have both in the fridge, just because I like margarine on bread, but would rather cook or bake with butter. Great hub, and more to think about. Thanks.

akeejaho profile image

akeejaho Hub Author 3 years ago

The marmalade sounds marvelous, the drippings however, do not. Thanks for sharing the info with me. It is always fun to learn something new, no matter how small it may be. I have never heard of drippings, but of course, I never had to experience eating them before. (Thankfully)

MrMarmalade profile image

MrMarmalade 3 years ago

Dripping is fat.

When you bake the meat for dinner, The grease, the oil, or the fat out of the meat solidifys. Then you spread on your toast. During the australian Depression, that is all my father could afford. In those days bread without some moisture was bad.

Now days no butter or margerine just Frank's Famous Farmalade marmalade.

Good for your health

akeejaho profile image

akeejaho Hub Author 3 years ago

Thanks Stevemark for the info and the visit.  Next time I go to the city I will look for it.  I live in a small town and the grocery store here is less then desirable.

Bonnie, I suppose it is all in how you look at things.  I prefer still to go the more natural route and no matter what, I still believe Butter is better.  (But I'm stubborn and I can't use clarified margarine to make my Shrimp Scampi!)

Thanks for stopping by, and for your thoughts.

MrMarmalade, I'm with you.  Hot Cross buns with lotsabutter!  Yum!  Now that's passion!  (Pardon my ignorance, and forgive me, I'm a Yank.  What, pray tell, are drippings?  They don't sound to pleasent, that's for sure.) 

Thanks for your input.  So far I think butter has the popular vote.  (Not that it means anything.  Just check out some of our presidential elections!) 

MrMarmalade profile image

MrMarmalade 3 years ago

When I was young I loved butter. Then some one told me to eat margarine.

Why I don't know?

Then the next person told me that butter was yellow and this other substance starts off before processing as black. Total confusion and gullible.

I was confused, so I stopped eating butter or Margarine completely. Well that's not true I love hot cross buns dripping with butter. Don't tell anyone, please.

Incidentally when I was a small boy we had to eat dripping. That was pretty horrible.

bonnieweelass profile image

bonnieweelass 3 years ago

Nice hub, I always thought that margarine is healthier than butter, that's why, I prefer margarine, now I know, thanks.

stevemark122000 profile image

stevemark122000 Level 1 Commenter 3 years ago

Butter is way healthier than most margarines, but there are margarines that you can buy at some grocery stores that are cold pressed, contain only healthy oils and have no hydrogenated oils or trans fats. One I have been using for years is called Earth Balance. Nice Hub!

Karen N profile image

Karen N Level 3 Commenter 3 years ago

Good hub, I think that natural is almost always better :)

akeejaho profile image

akeejaho Hub Author 3 years ago

Thanks Holly. Everything in moderation is a good thing.

Holly 3 years ago

Butter is small quantity is good. Not otherwise.

akeejaho profile image

akeejaho Hub Author 3 years ago

Wiser words have never been spoken MD. Thanks for the contribution.

MD FREE profile image

MD FREE 3 years ago

As a rule of thumb, if your grandmother wouldn't know what it is or how to make it, don't eat it!

funride profile image

funride 3 years ago

LOL, I´m sorry if I ruined your fun but I couldn´t keep my mouth :P

You don´t believe Bubble gum has spider eggs!? They´re the best protein source :D . Now seriously, you have to try some margarine without eating the package LOL.

I should be glad, it was the first time someone called me smarty pants (I think it was a compliment. Am I right?) LEOL (laughing extremely out loud) :D

akeejaho profile image

akeejaho Hub Author 3 years ago

Migraine! Lol. Too funny!

akeejaho profile image

akeejaho Hub Author 3 years ago

Oh, okay, you got me Funride. That Oleo (God I am so old) is close to plastic is one of those Urban legends. (Kinda like "Bubble Yum" bubble gum has spider eggs.) Ever hear that one?

Any way, to set the record straight, Funreide is right and Akeejaho was, (Ugh I hate to admit it.) Wrong! Wrong! Wrong!

What I meant to say is, it tastes like plastic. (Now argue that one! LOL)

Thanks for keeping me honest!

And thanks to you Bob and Patty. Keep it up and soon you will be honorary Bipolars! (You too Funride, Mr smarty pants!) LOL

funride profile image

funride 3 years ago

You know what, none of these foods are healthy LOL.

It´s a fact that butter contains more saturated fats and trans fat than margarine. Butter also contains dietary cholesterol. One thing I can´t agree with you it´s when you say that margarine it´s almost plastic. Do you know that butter it´s made from animal fats and margarine it´s made from vegetable fats? I know I know, there are lots of websites saying that margarine it´s "almost" plastic but none prove those allegations. It has been scientifically proved that margarine (when substituting butter) helps preventing heart diseases.

I agree with you about moderated consume of both (or just one of them) being the best way to help your health.

ps: If you ask me, I also prefer the taste of butter. Shhhh... :D

Bob Ewing profile image

Bob Ewing Level 3 Commenter 3 years ago

Butter is Better, good slogan, good hub.

Patty Inglish, MS profile image

Patty Inglish, MS Level 7 Commenter 3 years ago

Occhhh! - I thought the title said "Butter or Migraine?" lol

Submit a Comment
You Must Sign In To Comment

To comment on this Hub, you must sign in or sign up and post using a HubPages account.

Please wait working